Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

A Practical Guide to Improving Temperature Measurement Accuracy

A TDZ3 temperature transmitter can provide a good system option.
A TDZ3 temperature transmitter can provide a good system option.

Some processes do not require temperature measurement accuracy, and others do. However, you may be unsure whether accuracy is important for your particular application, or whether improving accuracy will make enough of a difference in your process results to justify the cost and effort. This article identifies problems that result from inaccurate measurements and outlines ways to solve them that are both effective and economical.

Temperature measurements can be categorized into three groups:

Those which do not require accuracy. You simply need to know if the temperature is stable or going up or going down.

Those which do require accuracy. Strategies in this article will help with those measurements.

Those where there is uncertainty about the accuracy requirement. If the measurements in this category are on a Preventive Maintenance schedule for calibration or verification you may want to take steps to improve accuracy. The same steps we take to achieve higher accuracy also result in reduced drift and that would have a positive impact on your maintenance frequency.

Improving accuracy and reducing measurement drift are often related and can have measureable results. There are a number of steps involved in selecting the best sensor for the application, reducing errors caused by external environment or caused by lead wires, and reducing measurement errors.

Sensors and accuracy

There are times when the temperature sensor is selected based on convenience, what is on the shelf or the “plant standard.” It is not uncommon to see a Type J or K thermocouple measuring a temperature that should be measured with a Platinum RTD (resistance thermometer).

Many process engineers and technicians prefer RTDs. Selecting the best sensor for the application greatly affects the accuracy of the measurement and an RTD is the most accurate sensor to use when the process temperature is within its measuring range. But you will need to use less accurate thermocouples when you need to measure temperatures that are hotter than the RTD’s upper measuring limits. In these instances you will want to take specific steps with thermocouples to improve the accuracy of the measurement results.

You can improve sensor accuracy by using thermocouples constructed with Special Tolerance (also called Premium Grade) wire. The reduced error is achieved by using wire with higher purity alloys. At 500 degrees F (260 degrees C), the uncertainty of a Special Tolerance thermocouple is about ±2.0 degrees F (1.1 degrees C).

Sensor selection is very important to measurement accuracy. As stated above, a Class A Pt RTD uncertainty is about ±1.2 degrees F (±0.67 degrees C) at the same operating temperature. To simplify the process of choosing a sensor, you can operate from the assumption that changing from a Standard Grade thermocouple to a Premium Grade thermocouple cuts the error rate in half; changing from a Premium Grade thermocouple to a Class A RTD cuts the error in half again.

The role of thermocouple extension wire

Thermocouples wired back to a PLC or DCS must use thermocouple extension wire. Unfortunately the extension wire is yet another source of measurement error. Using standard grade J or K extension wire also adds another ±4 degrees F (±2.2 degrees C) error. You can cut the error rate by using premium grade extension wire, which has half the error rate of standard extension wire, just as with premium thermocouples. (These error figures are only true when the wire is new and “pure.”) Over time the error gets worse as the wire gets contaminated from the atmosphere in your plant and the wire is exposed to temperatures greater than or lower than the wire tolerances. There are many instances where contamination causes even more “drift” than the original uncertainty of new thermocouple wire.

If the uncertainty caused by thermocouples was a fixed offset, we could simply calibrate it out and be done with it. But when the error is in the form of drift that changes over time, calibration becomes a Preventive Maintenance program that few want to take on. Most plants prefer to avoid that extra labour whenever possible.

How do you solve these problems? Start by determining how much error is caused by the thermocouple extension wire. Most people overlook this option until Plant Operations declares there is a problem or a catastrophic measurement failure occurs. We all know thermocouples fail, but it is easy to forget that thermocouple extension wire also fails. When it does, it has to be replaced. If you replace the extension wire with new extension wire, you perpetuate the same problems by reintroducing the error and drift it causes.

You may have to live with thermocouples, but you don’t have to live with thermocouple extension wire – you can replace it with other solutions.

Two options for replacing thermocouple extension wire are temperature transmitters and remote I/O hardware. Both use copper wire to transport their signals back to the control system. Unlike thermocouple extension wire, you can expect the copper to last the life of the plant. Modern I/O products have performance characteristics similar to transmitters and can save a lot of money. You still need short sections of extension wire when you use these transmitters or I/O products. Use special grade thermocouple wire instead of standard extension wire in these cases to further minimize the error.

Compensating for lead wire inaccuracies

Copper wire is used for RTD lead wires. If you are familiar with 3-wire RTDs you know one lead is called the compensating lead. Between copper and a compensating lead you might believe that RTD lead wire does not contribute to the measurement error.

Unfortunately, this is not true. Copper wire can cause significant error in an RTD measurement because RTDs are resistors and copper wire is resistance. There are many contaminants in a typical process plant that cause corrosion and this corrosion changes the resistance of the copper lead wires. This resistance change in the lead wire can cause error. To eliminate lead wire error the solution is to use 4-wire RTDs.

Here is why: When a third lead wire is added to the RTD, the measurement is made with today’s electronics by taking two voltage measurements. The important thing to remember is that these are high impedance voltage measurements.

For all practical purposes, there is no current flow through that third lead.

V1 gives the value of the lead wire resistance R1. V2 gives the value of the RTD + R4 lead resistance. Subtract V1 from V2 and as long as the lead resistances R1 = R4, only the value of the RTD remains. This is an accurate measurement. Realize that too many things work against making R1 and R4 identical when accuracy is your primary concern. Wire gauge intolerance and work hardening varies the resistance.

Even if no human error takes place during installation, corrosion constantly works against the measurement and is the main reason R1 never equals R4. So what happens if the lead’s resistances are not equal? If the resistance imbalance is as little as 1 ohm, a 100Ω Pt RTD has an error of about ±4.7 degrees F (±2.6 degrees C). If you are trying to achieve a ±1 degrees F (.55 degrees C) measurement accuracy, this corrosion is standing between you and success. You can spend your life calibrating this error out or eliminate the error totally with a 4-wire RTD.

When using 4-wire RTDs, for all practical purposes, there is no error caused by the lead wire. 4-wire RTDs can have a lead wire of any length and the leads can undergo constant resistance change and still cause no measurement error. It is still important to ensure your total resistance does not exceed the drive capacity of your constant current source. Typically modern day temperature transmitters offer enough current drive to support RTD circuits that have up to 3-4K ohms of total resistance. With lead wire error eliminated you are able to focus on the sensor and measuring device to further reduce error.

The only reasonable objection to using the 4-Wire RTD is that the existing legacy input card only accepts 3-wire RTDs. This is old technology and should be considered for replacement.

There is another option to consider if you are not able to use 4-wire RTDs: switch from 100Ω Pt RTDs to 1000Ω Pt RTDs. Ω of resistance imbalance in the current carrying legs of a 100Ω Pt element produces about ±4.7 degrees F (±2.6 degrees C) error. If you change to a 1000Ω sensor that same 1Ω of imbalance will have one-tenth of the effect. The 1Ω of imbalance error drops to about ±0.47 degrees F (±0.26 degrees C).

While the use of the 1000Ω 3-wire RTD is a big improvement over the use of a 100Ω 3-wire RTD, it is not a panacea. When the lead wire resistance imbalance changes, that causes the measurement accuracy to change. That means you still need a calibration program to temporarily eliminate the error. The 4-wire RTD is still the single best solution because it removes all lead wire error and eliminates the need to calibrate due to the inevitable corrosion.

Plant noise

VFDs, motors and radios create “normal” levels of EMI and RFI which can cause errors on temperature measurements. Thermocouple and RTD signals are very low level mV signals. It does not take much noise to cause significant distortion of the measurements. If you are wiring these low level signals back to the control system please use best practices to keep noise off these signal wires by using drain wires, proper grounding and physical separation.

A better solution is to convert the low level signals to high level signals as close to the temperature sensor as possible. The same amount of noise will affect high signals less than low level signals. Signals like 4-20mA, HART or RS-485 survive most typical levels of noise.

Temperature measurement and remote I/O

When you finally get to the actual temperature measurement device your ability to make significant improvements to accuracy has passed. Modern temperature transmitters and temperature I/O systems from major instrument companies have similar performance specifications. If you are trying to differentiate the finer points you might compare these specifications:

  • The greater the input resolution the measuring circuit can detect, the smaller the changes in the sensor’s temperature can be detected
  • Long term drift spec is a measure of the transmitter’s stability 
  • RTD Excitation current should be low to minimize the self-heating error
  • Seek the highest Input Impedance possible so that the measuring device does not draw current
  • Advanced diagnostics help to predict failures

If you are pursuing the very highest accuracy, you have to deal with the final “as built” error in the RTD. The transmitter can be used to calibrate out that final offset error and match you to the ideal curve. Such a process delivers a typical transmitter and sensor combined accuracy of less than 0.05 percent of span.

Putting a temperature transmitter or remote I/O near your sensor digitizes your temperature measurement. You create two more errors if you then send that signal back to the control or data acquisition system using 4-20mA:

1. D/A error occurs when creating the 4-20mA

2. At the control system, an A/D error occurs when turning the signal back to digital Using the HART digital signal is one way to avoid the conversion errors. MODBUS Serial or MODBUS over Ethernet is another option to keep the measured value digital. 

Temperature sensors often require signal boosts for effective transmission.
Temperature sensors often require signal boosts for effective transmission.

Company Info

Related News

Honeywell to provide process automation and safety systems for new liquefied natural gas facility in Canada

Honeywell will serve as Integrated Main Automation Contractor for Goldboro Plant

Honeywell Process Solutions (HPS) has announced it will provide full automation and safety systems and serve as integrated main automation contractor (I-MAC) for a new liquefied natural gas (LNG) facility being built in Eastern Canada to process North American natural gas for international export. Honeywell technology is currently being used in more than 40 similar LNG import and export terminals around the world.

Read More

Optical gas imagers offer options for leak detection

Seeking out potential gas leaks with optical gas imaging tools is becoming an alternative to traditional vapour analysis.

The discovery of a massive methane leak at the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage facility near Los Angeles in October 2015 brought national attention to safety and environmental concerns over natural gas production, processing and storage. The well blowout released an estimated 97,100 metric tons of methane and 7,300 metric tons of ethane over a fourmonth period, making it the largest natural gas leak in the United States’ history.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Honeywell Process controls improving operator efficiency and productivity at Russian refinery

The Experion HS process automation system meets Kuban’s unit control and data collection requirements, enabling control and monitoring systems to operate with enhanced stability and reliability.

Honeywell Process Solutions (HPS) has announced that its Experion HS process automation system has been implemented at Kuban Oil and Gas Company’s Ilsky Refinery, one of the largest refineries in Russia’s Krasnodar Territory.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

New innovation lowers the total cost of ownership for customers that require active static grounding protection

The Earth-Rite MULTIPOINT II is a unique static grounding system that can monitor the simultaneous grounding of up to eight (8) individual pieces of equipment at risk of discharging electrostatic sparks.

Newson Gale’s Earth-Rite MULTIPOINT II is the new innovation which will provide customers with a unique value proposition that makes the active static grounding of multiple items of equipment with interlock control more cost effective than other options available to the EX/HAZLOC industries.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Drexelbrook offers Density Compensation Module for Universal IV Water Cut Monitor

Drexelbrook Universal IV Cut Monitor with Density Compensation Module.

AMETEK Drexelbrook now offers a Density Compensation Module (DCM) for its Universal IV In-Line Water Cut Monitor (CM). The module automatically compensates for density changes that may occur in the composition of products and reduces the calibration requirements due to those changes.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

System measures density of varied fluids

Dynatrol CL-10HY Density Systems achieve exceptional accuracy over a wide range of process changes in ambient temperature, pressure, viscosity or flow.

Measure the density of crude oil, butane, diesel fuel, distillates, gasoline, ethane gas, isobutene, jet fuels, LPG, such as kerosene or propane using a Dynatrol CL-10-HY density cell and Series 2000 density digital converter.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Downturn means efficient automation drawing attention from oil industry

A range of exhibitors and attendees will be in Edmonton for the 2016 AEC Alberta conference.

In a downturn such as the one the Canadian oil and gas industry is facing, operators spend much of their time looking for ways to save money. Efficiency is a key part of that process, and that often leads toward the use of automation in many parts of the operation – automation that reduces costs while increasing production.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Wireless “bread crumbs” lead to faster response in oilfields

Connected wireless networks allow for quicker response to issues and greater efficiency.

Think about the maintenance required to service a typical oilfield. Hundreds of wells spaced out over many square kilometres all need constant monitoring to ensure that each is operating properly and producing hydrocarbons at peak efficiency. A poorly functioning well can bleed the operator thousands of dollars daily. Just one pump operating at a sub-optimal level can cost an oil and gas company thousands of gallons each day in lost production. Worse yet, if a well runs dry without the operator knowing it, the downhole pump could burn out, precipitating an expensive repair.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Wireless remote shutdown systems

Example of a wireless remote shutdown system with all communications links among the sensors, remote shutdown system and PLC guarded to assure fail safe operations.

The hurricane hit three days ago. Huge, it both flooded and littered debris on roads, creating a state of emergency. The good news: half your wells are still in production. The bad news: your SCADA system is still down and you think three tank batteries might be full but your pumper and the tanker can’t get there. There is a berm, but it might be flooded and any spill is bad for business.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

OMEGA introduces two new enhanced data loggers

Intrinsically Safe Temperature Data Logger.

The OMEGA OM-CP-TEMP1000IS-A and OM-CP-RHTEMP1000IS-A intrinsically safe data loggers offer a compact design and portability which allows for placement into hard to reach locations. Features include a 316 stainless steel enclosure, fast response times, and faster downloads. OMEGA offers a docking station for full communications, no more removal of end-caps to download data. By utilizing the latest software, data can be downloaded or exported for easy analysis.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Comparing position sensor technologies for hydraulic cylinder feedback

Feature-by-feature comparison of magnetostrictive, variable resistance and variable inductance sensors.

Position feedback sensors for hydraulic or pneumatic cylinders have used one of three traditional technologies: magnetostrictive, variable resistance and variable inductance sensors. While other sensor technologies have occasionally been used successfully in this application, the focus of this article is the comparison among these three most popularly used technologies.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Natural gas production experiencing a ‘golden age’ of wireless data collection

Wireless technologies are particularly well-suited to use in remote areas.

Canada is the world’s fourth leading producer of natural gas and production is continuing to trend upward, with approximately 5,500 billion cubic feet of gas produced in 2014 according to Canada’s National Energy Board. Additionally, nearly 8,000 new wells were drilled, an increase of more than 25 percent over 2013. The growth in natural gas production – most of which takes place in British Columbia and Alberta – shows no sign of diminishing.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Gas sampling pump for low pressure applications

SP0V-100PSIG-D Gas Sampling Pump

Because the composition of natural gas changes over time due to changes in the natural gas reservoir and other factors there is a need to sample the gas to determine its composition. Sampling of natural gas to determine the composition is important for custody transfer and fiscal metering so that both buyers and sellers are confident of a fair transaction. Contracts are typically concerned with the BTU or energy content of the gas and the hydrocarbon dew point of the gas. There are many robust automatic gas sampling systems such as on-line GCs (Gas Chromatographs) in the field that can perform on-line sampling. These are systems are expensive, require frequent maintenance and are usually only justified when large volumes of gas are being moved.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Design utility increases safety and cuts costs

Honeywell’s UniSim design and simulation software is designed specifically for oil and gas, petrochemical and chemical industry applications.

Honeywell Process Solutions has added a key enhancement to its UniSim design and simulation software designed to help manufacturing facilities improve safety and reduce capital expenditures for both new and existing installations.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Cloud technology provides basis for advanced telematics development

The wilds of Mozambique were a good test bed for telematics solutions aiding oil and gas companies with their asset tracking needs.

It was early days for the Internet of Things (IoT) when CAN Telematics founder Brent Moore flew to Mozambique, Africa to deliver an advanced IoT solution. Built entirely on Microsoft technology, it established a pattern of IoT leadership that would earn CAN Telematics a reputation as a visionary in the emerging field of telematics with their Trakopolis software.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Harnessing satellite technology for innovation and profitability in the oil and gas market

The RMU1 automated remote monitoring by Mobiltex Data powered by the Globalstar STX3 simplex global transmitter for cathodic monitoring of remote gas pipelines.

For companies operating in Canada’s oil and gas industry, harnessing the power of satellite technology is helping to open up new avenues for operational productivity and profitability. At a time when crude oil prices struggle to stay above $50 a barrel, and companies are trying to stay competitive in a global, data-driven mobile marketplace, satellite communications technology is helping oil and gas companies address key operational challenges and drive cost savings.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Sine wave filters for VFD motor drives

Sine wave filters FN 5040 HV

The new lineup of Sine wave filters from Schaffner EMC eliminate premature motor damage caused by high dv/dt, overvoltages, cable ringing, motor overheating and eddy current losses caused by variable frequency drives (VFD). Suitable for motor frequencies up to 600 Hz, this proven technology converts the rectangular PWM output voltage of motor drives into a smooth sine wave with low residual ripple. In addition to elongating service life of expensive high speed motors, Schaffner sine wave filters can improve bearing life by eliminating circulating bearing currents.

Read More

Tags
Instrumentation, Systems & Automation

Honeywell’s enhanced RTU2020 process controller simplifies management of distributed oil and gas assets

Honeywell Process Solutions-RTU2020 01CRIO Redundant Controler With Two Expansion IO modules

Honeywell Process Solutions (HPS) has launched its newest RTU2020 process controller, which helps operating companies in oil and gas, mining and other process industries effectively manage complex remote automation and control applications.

Read More